Group Critique Mash-up project

Within your groups of three or four, view and discuss the work of each group member.

Which design seems the most compelling? Why? Evaluate along:

• Overall concept
• Strong design elements (color, texture, composition, etc.)
• Interesting visual interactions between layers / components
• How do the photoshop / layer techniques support the idea?

Which design seems the least compelling? Why?

How could the strongest design be improved? What is the weakest element?

Are there aspects of the lesser designs that could be incorporated into the stronger?

Are there completely new directions / tangents suggested by the work?

-------------------------------------------------------------

Take the feedback into consideration and revise one piece to "completion"